Challenge: It's B&W to me



Thanks to Wilk for hosting the Go Wide challenge. There were a lot of great images posted. I also want to thank Wilk for asking me to host the next challenge.

I wanted to take us out of our comfort zone with the new challenge (this includes me). A lot of ideas came to me, but I finally settled on a black and white theme. I'm a color guy from way back, having been a slide shooter before I went digital, so this is relatively new territory for me. However, it certainly does take me back to my roots in photographic terms. Perhaps the same will be true for you.

The new challenge is all about black and white images. So, here are the rules of engagement. Slight tinting is okay, but no spot coloring. New images are preferred. Other than that, there are no holds barred.

For those of you that aren't sure how to process for black and white in Photoshop, I created a short black and white processing tutorial slideshow. I show two ways of doing it; one for CS3 and one for older versions of Photoshop. If you don't have Photoshop, you can download a 30-day trial version at no cost at this link: http://www.adobe.com/products/photoshop/photoshop/

If you're shooting in digital, I encourage you to shoot in color and then convert to black and white in post-processing. You'll get much richer tones that way.

For example images, I went back to the scene of the 35W bridge collapse at sunrise yesterday. I thought that this subject would be stark in black and white. I found the scene to be powerful. This image shows the wide view of the scene of the collapse. The shadows being cast on the ruins are from the 10th Avenue Bridge, where I was standing to get this shot.

One other thing I think is interesting to experiment with in black and white is images that stay mostly in the shadows. I know we tend to think of high contrast when we think black and white. I captured these images at the Walker Art Center at the Sculpture Garden. I like the way the early morning sun outlines the face. These two images are actually a fair bit darker on Photographica than they appear on my computer because the color profile info is stripped from the image when we upload to Photographica. I have found through painful experimenting that this causes trouble for black and white images that are on the dark side because a ton of shadow detail is clipped. So if your images tend to run darker, you might want to try lightening them up a bit before uploading them to Photographica. I had to do that with most of mine.

So that's it, black and white. I know there are a lot of folks here that prefer color. I'm usually one of them. However, I think black and white is great for getting us to really focus on composition and foreground/background. After all, we can't rely on color to draw the viewer's attention where we want it to go.

Have fun with it. I look forward to seeing lots of interesting black and white images. I'll do my best to comment on all the challenge postings.


 
  • ClassyShots
    Good challenge idea Tom! I know that "Black and White" has always been the term used for these images but I really dislike it because it is misleading. While it it is true that some of your highlights may be white and shadows may be black it is really more about the tonal range between the two and the contrast. To those of you that don't shoot for b&w on a regular basis, you will learn to see things much differently than you would if you were shooting color. It really is a different world. If you are shooting with a Canon and shoot in RAW mode you can set your camera to shoot RAW + JPG and set the camera in the B&W mode. The jpg's will be b&w and your RAW's will be in color. It will give you an idea of what you are going to end up with that way when you check the image on your LCD and give you the chance to re shoot at a different exposure if you think you can make it better. I try to make it a habit to shoot for b&w for at least a few images any time I'm out. It will help clear your head and eyes and get a new look at things. If you are an Adobe Lightroom user be sure to check out the b&w conversion in it!!! Anymore that is the only thing I use on my conversions.

    - Oh Bull!


  • fuzzy1
    all I have to say is: WOO HOO !!! fun, fun, fun! (can you tell I really love black and white?)

    - f8 and be there...


  • tomnorth
    Good idea about shooting RAW + jpg. I've always been looking for a good reason to shoot RAW +jpg. You've just given me one.

    - One size does not fit all


  • Sopris
    Excellent challenge Tom! The bridge shots are very powerful!

  • Penny
    I agree with Sopris about the bridge shots. I will love this challenge. Thanks to Wilk for a fun challenge.

    - Smile


  • Candice
    Thanks Wilk for a terriffic challenge! Tom, I can't wait to see what's posted. With the age of digital, you don't get to experience the "magic" of the darkroom...but shooting for b/w will encourage us to "see" thru different eyes!

  • Wildman
    Good timing! Think everyone is in the mood for ebony and ivory!

  • enigmaticfaerie
    Woo! Too bad I'm not taking a B&W class this semester... but that's ok. I still have plenty to shoot. Thanks to wilk for the 'go wide' challenge. It was nice to see everyone's shots.

    - Film-junkie: Back in 2008


  • loweho
    Great idea, Tom, I'll have to get out his week and do some shooting before we leave on vacation. Try to get the eyes seeing values instead of colors. Should be fun. Thanks to Wilk for the Go Wide challenge produced a lot of great photos and was fun too.

    - Fickle Finger of F8


  • bullshoalsview
    Thanks Wilk for a wonderful wide challenge, what fun! BW will be a challenge for me, as I am a colorful girl.... Great examples Tom.... this will be challenging!

    - Run Bubba Run!


  • Ashton
    Whoot great challeng! Thanks Wilk for the go wide challenge! Can't wait to see all that comes about this time! I knew that about RAW+jpeg but had forgotten thanks for the reminder!

    - Say...CHEESE


  • Pablo57
    Thank you Wilk for the go wide! challenge. I'm looking forward to the it's black and white to me challenge. Thanks Tom. Growing up in the early 60s TV and photos were only B&W and I'm awaking with this challenge. I'm especially looking forward to experimenting with staying in the shadows.

  • Penny
    Tom who is doing the next challenge? Just curious so that you can contact them so they have time to get it ready by the end of this one. So we don't have down time again.....

    - Smile


  • wilk
    If your goal is to get us out of our comfort zone, does that I have to shoot my black and whites in color?

    -      Oh Shoot


  • tomnorth
    Good point. Nah, you can teach us all something about black and white.

    - One size does not fit all


  • auntilaila
    Yeah wilk, teach us this time. i need obvious help. No idea about black and white. Just shoot and it goes on camera, i play with it to enhance and brighten but Kodak does not offer much help for me YET. I will give it a Shot (excuse the pun)

    - 50 is easy


  • grami
    Thanks Wilk for your wide challenge...it really made me realize how often I miss the larger picture. This B/W challenge is going to be a learning event for me Tom. Thanks. Your examples are very helpful.

Only registered users are allowed to post comments. Please sign in or create an account.