NYC Photo Comparison Part 3 of 3 - 1945 to 2006

By Pablo57
6
written 11/25/07 4:47 PM, published 11/26/07 6:00 PM
This is Part 3, the final episode, of a photo comparison between Don Philip's 1945 photos and my photos taken in 2006-7.  See the genral forum for more information.
   
To view these photos, open as usual, maximize the photo window by click the little box in the upper right corner, click once in the window anywhere to lock it, then use the scroll bars. Close the window by clicking on the X in the upper right corner.

NY Harbor Views, July 5th, 2006. – the three photos are from the Staten Island ferry which runs from Lower Manahattan to Staten Island.  The ferry is free, there are no lines like at the Statue of Liberty ferries and the view is spectacular.  I would suggest a ride if you are in town.

Statue of Liberty.  Not much has changed here.  Our lady of the harbor is still greeting the immigrants.  She is a witness.  Statue of Liberty

This photo and the next one could have been taken seconds apart.  If you are on a ship entering the harbor and look to the left you’ll see the statue and if you look ahead you’ll see the next photo.

NY Harbor and Lower Manhattan as seen from a ship in the harbor.  Don’s photo shows the George Washington Bridge in the upper left corner.  This is truly amazing.  I do not recall ever seeing a photo that shows the Battery and the George Washington Bridge.  The bridge is just too far away. Don’s photo is looking up the Hudson River to the west.  My photo shows the Brooklyn Bridge in the lower right corner looking up the East River and also shows a shadow of the Empire State Building.  The Brooklyn Bridge is very close to the Battery.NY Harbor Lower Manhattan Skyline

Battery Park as seen from a ship.  Don’s photo is looking East, my photo is looking North.  Most of the buildings in Don’s photo are still standing. Castle Clinton is very significant in Don’s photo.  In my photo the fort is in the middle of the photo behind a ferry and is dwarfed by the Wall Street towers.  The significant building in my photo is the Woolworth building, just seen looking up Broadway. Battery Park

A final word - The hairs on my arms stood up as I took several of these photos.  The time between 1945 and 2006 may seem long, but it is as long as the wink of an eye.  The time it takes for the little snow flake stars to fall in a crystal ball of New York City.



 
  • Penny
    7
    Another great comparison. Great job Pablo

    - Smile

    Please sign in to rate.


  • kitzi
    6
    you are so right about time...the more of it I have behind me, the faster it goes. Scary. But you're comparisons are without compare..thanks for the lovely nostalgic tour.

    - ©kitzi

    Please sign in to rate.


  • What a great project! I hate for it to stop. And I'm anxious to hear Don's comments on the re-imaging.

    - blow.....hard

    Please sign in to rate.


  • Ashton
    3
    I too hate to see it end! I'm so glad to have seen these shots.

    - Say...CHEESE

    Please sign in to rate.


  • loweho
    6
    Another great effort, Pablo! It's neter than heck to see the changes and similarities in the photos. Hate to see it end.

    - Fickle Finger of F8

    Please sign in to rate.


  • Thanks.....

    - WoooHo-Ho-Ho-Hooo...

    Please sign in to rate.


  • bugaboo
    4
    I have so enjoyed this series, and hate to see it end, thank you for bringing it to us! Time... yep it is a wicked fast thing isn't it?

    Please sign in to rate.


  • fuzzy1
    4
    I've really enjoyed looking at all of these. You did a wonderful job with what must have been a really big project. Well done....

    - f8 and be there...

    Please sign in to rate.


  • Excellent series.

    - A quack with an camera

    Please sign in to rate.


  • Bugsy
    3
    I have truly enjoyed viewing what you have shared! Great job, and well put together. Thanks for sharing.

    - Just trying to bee..

    Please sign in to rate.


  • Cool project...Loved that you shared it with all of us... :)

    - Have a nice day...

    Please sign in to rate.


  • Anonymous User
    1
    i missed the 1st two parts (i'm new to internet) i loved part 3. having lived there in mid 60's brought back many memories.

    Please sign in to rate.


  • Pyro43
    6
    Very nice, Pablo. Your research paid off.

    - Mmmmmm... Multiplicative

    Please sign in to rate.


  • RobinG
    3
    Excellent job! I enjoyed these posts immensely. Thanks for sharing. :o)

    Please sign in to rate.


  • Sopris
    4
    These are sooo cool!

    Please sign in to rate.


  • colbb
    3
    Good, real good, great, oh hell, Super! Even SG is near speechless.

    Please sign in to rate.


  • Again I can't thank you enough for using my old photographs of NY for your comparison shots. I must have been like a scavenger hunt! I know you had fun doing it, and you did a marvelous job .

    - Don

    Please sign in to rate.


Only registered users are allowed to post comments. Please sign in or create an account.